Case Study

Driving Results for an Auto Insurance Marketer with Direct Mail Testing

Auto Insurance

CLIENT:

Auto Insurance Marketer

CHALLENGE:

An auto insurance company wanted to explore direct mail as a customer acquisition channel but was unsure how to effectively target the right audience. They needed a strategic approach to test direct mail while ensuring a strong return on investment.

SOLUTION:

We developed a data-driven direct mail strategy, with a full turnkey solution, leveraging audience segmentation and life-event targeting to identify high-intent prospects. By testing multiple creative formats, messaging variations, and offer structures, the client was able to optimize engagement and response rates.

Implementation

  • Targeting Precision: Used demographic, behavioral, and life events to create high-converting audience segments.
  • A/B Testing: Ran controlled tests with different creative approaches, formats, messaging styles, and incentives.
  • Performance Tracking: Measured response rates, conversions, and policy sign-ups to refine targeting and messaging.

 

RESULTS:

The campaign yielded a positive ROI in the first mailing and the client is now currently looking to successfully scale their direct mail efforts based on insights gained from initial testing.

By combining data-driven targeting with a structured testing framework, SMS helped this insurance company unlock the potential of direct mail, turning it into a scalable and profitable marketing channel.

Thanks for your inquiry

Your submission has been received, and we will be in touch shortly.